Thursday, October 16, 2008

The Research Process Part 2

The Research Process Part 2
(General Guidelines For Building a Good Paper)



Focusing Your Topic

By this point you know a lot about what you will be writing about. You’ve done background research—reading about the history of the topics, discovering who some key players are in this debate and mapping out the various positions held in the controversy. Now, you are ready to add your opinion to the larger academic discussion about this topic.

But why?

Failing to focus a topic is a common mistake students make. When the topic is too broad, there is too much to cover, which results in a paper that feels superficial or shallow. If you topics is too narrow—i.e. “what are the psychological effects of 7 am classes on CCD students with brown, well kept hair…” you won’t be able to find enough evidence to support your points.

What does this mean?

Focusing a research topic (or occasionally broadening it) is narrowing your topic (and choosing to focus on specific parts of it) so that you can demonstrate your

Let’s say you like animals. Developing a focus for your paper (and your research) means you start here:
Animals have feelings
And go here:
The use of dogs in the United States Military is useful, but at what cost?

This isn’t necessarily your thesis, but it has narrowed your interests into something you can work with. The point is with the later you have specific research needs; you are working with a specific type of animal in a specific situation—something you can tackle in 10-15 pages.


Note: You will not immediately know what your focus should be. It will come to you, most likely, through trial and error, through reading a lot articles and other literature that you will not ultimately use. Realize, you are shaping your thinking on this topic and as you learn more, your thoughts will change.



Start by defining your terms. How can your terms be broken down?
Example:
War is wrong

Defining the terms:
"War": What type (self-defense, aggressive preemptive strikes, rooted in ideology…)? By whom? What commonalities do you see in the wars you think are wrong?
"Wrong": How so? Results in unnecessary bloodshed? Has a drastic effect on the economy? Fail to foresee and plan for the complexities on the ground?
Focused:
In American history, wars that are rooted in ideology often have dire consequences for the economy.
You can always define again, and again, if need be. Do you see how this is putting the proper restraint on the topic? How you can now find specific examples and evidence to support this idea?



Try focusing on:

A specific location: Colorado’s community colleges have the best students.
Age group: Violence on television begets violence among pre-Kinder kids.
Species: While testing cosmetic products must be done, Chimpanzees should be spared because…
Ethnicity: What are the effects of our current immigration laws on Mexican-American families in the US?

Do Not Merely Restate Terms. War is bad because it’s war. No. Don’t do it.


Most of all, this is the moment to consider your approach to the subject. Are you writing about a specific element of smoking (marketing to children in Third World Countries) or about its more general elements (Smoking is still a big problem among today’s youth). You have to figure out where to go and how to get there.

Test your topic early. The night before a draft is due is a poor time to discover your topic is still too broad. The research process is a recursive one. You will need to come back to your topic time and time again if it isn’t working out. A lot of this is Goldilocks and porridge. You have to try a lot to find what is just right. Remember—Writing takes time.

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Research Process Part 1

What is research? Why do we do it? While we all know we need it—for papers, to win arguments, to be better people—how to do it, and where to even start, is often difficult.

The problem is so often we are just told, “do research.” We know there’s a library and some fancy databases, but that doesn’t always help us. For most us, we don’t sit down with a thesis statement ready to go, we just have a vague idea of something we are interested in (which is why we do research to begin with).

The first goal of any researcher is to become familiar with the topic. This means doing background research and building our expertise on the subject. We may not know what we want to write about, but we are interested in food production. Our background research will help define what under the subject of food production we are interested in. The following is more of a guide than a science, but here are some ideas on process:

Step 1:

Find a good, meaty topic. You need something you can sink your teeth into, but this is easier said than done. There are plenty of places to turn for ideas. Check out:
• Speakout.com
• Google, “controversial topics” see what turns up
• Nytimes.com—op eds, et.
• Procon.org
• Dir.yahoo.com/society_and_culture/issues_and_culture
• Where are some places you turn to find topics?


Step 2:
Turn your topic into a question. For example, if you are interested in finding out about food production, pose the question, “What are the effects of food production?” However, just these questions won’t suffice. What are some other questions you need to ask? “What effect do food additives have on nutrition?” “How is food produced and delivered to consumers?” Already, we are spinning our wheels. Depending on your topic, you may need to develop a list of questions you want answered. Just by doing this we are getting into the topic further. As you look around, more questions will pop up.

Develop some questions based on your own topic.

Step 3:

Find background info. Develop your expertise on the topic. You will never write a good paper if you don’t know what you are writing about (just like you will never speak beautifully in Korean if you don’t first learn the Korean language).

Places to go for background info:
• Reference works. Encyclopedias. Online—Wikipedia (keeping in mind it can be biased), encyclopedia.com, etc—or the good old fashioned kind. Dictionaries. Overviews of topics, people, places, events.
• Subject encyclopedias. Ency. on specific subjects. Ie: Ency of Bioethics, Ency. of Sociology, Int. Ency. of Higher Ed.
• Current Issues research. Look in newspapers (nytimes.com), procon.org, yahoo. Etc.
• Heck, google.com. But be weary, just because it’s on the internet doesn’t mean it is any good.

Now what:

You have already done a lot, but you are just starting. Now you should know enough to start focusing your topic. New questions have emerged.

Important—start keeping track of your information. Print it out. Start a word document and paste all your sources in there with a summary of what they are good for. Do what you need to do to help yourself remember this stuff later (to save you time).

Remember:

Research is pealing potatoes, not garnishing a Coq Au Vin. (If you want to see what Coq Au Vin looks like, click here and while you are there, epicurious.com is a good place to figure out what to make for dinner). There are many steps, some will not be productive, some will. But you have to do it or you will suffer later. So get to the computers, go to the library and research!

Writing about the death penalty

This is NOT your reading for next class. But it is interesting. If you are interested in Capital Punishment, check this out.

Also, I just found this on the NYTIMES.COM website. This is a really cool feature--from bloggingheads.com and I will be posting more links in the future.

Monday, October 13, 2008

Read this

Read this, by Roberts Miller. We'll discuss on thurs.

Also, there will be more posts with links as I find them on subjects that might be useful to you.

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Schedule Change (revised): Due Date Analysis of Controversy

Assignment: Analysis of the Controversy

Due 10/21
Pts: 100

This a 2-5 page paper that shows you know the field you are writing about and its literature. You will discuss the background of the subject (people started disagreeing about this when....for example, Matthew Shephard’s violent death brought to light the extreme violence many gays are faced with. Since then other topics of gay rights have moved to the forefront of our culture, including gay marriage. In 2004, Massachusetts made it legal to..."

Some points to consider:
* what “events” turned this issue into a controversy in the first place
* who this controversy affects
* how the outcome of the controversy might affect that population
* why it’s important to others (why should anyone else care?)

You will not make an argument here, but summarize what each side of this debate say. AGAIN. YOU ARE NOT PROVING YOUR SIDE OF THE ARGUMENT. YOU MIGHT NOT EVEN HAVE A SIDE YET. This is just a summation of all the preliminary research you have done on a topic. For the various positions/stances in controversy, look at:

* the reasons offered in support of these positions
* the persuasive styles not directly linked to “logical reasons” (appeals to emotion or the author’s credibility, etc. This could be a Pastor making an argument FOR gay marriage and using the bible as his evidence. He has ETHOS.)
* common rhetorical figures (metaphors, metonymies, analogies, etc.) utilized in making the persuasive case
* what’s at stake in upholding this position (who are the winners and losers—including any secret beneficiaries? What will be won or lost? etc.)

You assignment here, to be clear, is to accurately summarize your topic (not your argument) and present a Wikipedia-like discussion of it--broken down into sections that point out its important elements, important scholars working in this area, and what people disagree about in regards to this subject. Map the various positions held, and explain what they stand for.

Also, look and how some of these debates can be focused into topics that you can write about (ie if you are writing about the debate of sex education, you could add a section that explains

You will need to cite your source material. To do so, use your Hacker handbook and follow the instructions for MLA citation style.

What Should I Be Doing...Research!

I didn't have enough time in our shortened class to talk about this much so here are some research strategies that I recommend to all of you.

1. Reread the assignment (hint: it is attached below. You have to click "older posts" until you see it.). See your Hacker handbook for some advice if you don't understand it.

2. Begin some preliminary research. Your goal is to become an expert on the subject you are writing about. Search the databases, yes, but also look for some good general information (magazine articles, wikipedia, yahoo directory, etc) that will give you the background info. on the topic.

3. Do more research (you are going to hear this phrase a lot). Begin to focus your topic. Log on to owl.english.purdue.edu and do a search on research. This will really help. Also, go back to the Hacker, to Ch. 16 & 17 in your Good Reasons book.

More later.

Monday, October 6, 2008

Reminder

Tomorrow's class is in the Enhanced Learning Center in the Library, as announced on the syllabus.

Those of you who turned in proposals will get them back with my comments.

Be ready to do some research on your prospective topic.